Favorite Podcasts

The 23 Best True Crime Podcasts (Like Serial and S-Town) [Updated May 2021]

9 min read

Within the last few years, the genre of true crime has exploded in popularity. 

In the wake of legendary podcasts such as Criminal, S-Town and Serial, true crime junkies have been flooding out of the woodwork. Due to their gripping stories and execution of research (no pun intended), these are some of the most consumed true crime podcasts of our time.

If you have already binged these podcasts, chances are you are looking for your next true crime fix. If so, you are in the right place. 

Below we have listed some of the best up and coming true crime podcasts of 2021. These shows have either just made an appearance, or are finally catching their wave of recognition. Either way, these are some of the podcasts we feel are worth giving a download this year. 

Launching a True Crime podcast of your own?

With Castos’ Podcast Launch Service, our team of professional audio engineers, show note writers, and marketing pros work with you to create marketing assets, map out episodes, and make sure your podcast is set up for success. Enter your information to request a free consultation.

  1. In the Dark 

The ongoing search for eleven year old Jacob Wetterling, is still to this day one of the biggest search efforts in US history. The manhunt for the killer had hundreds of national guardsmen sweeping the Minnesota countryside. Not only did the disappearance of Jacob Weterling send a cold chill into the hearts of parents nationwide, it gave birth to the term “stranger danger.” Serial investigative journalist, Madeleine Baran, takes you on a journey through this heart wrenching case. In the Dark takes a deep dive into what went wrong within the investigation, and why Jacob Wetterling’s remains have yet to be found. 

Listen to In The Dark

  1. Unraveled: Long Island Serial Killer 

Imagine a murder case in which the chief of police is the prime suspect. It’s been more than ten years since eleven dismembered bodies were discovered, strewn along the coast of Long Island. Within this seven part podcast investigative journalists, Billy Jensen and Alexis Linkietter, explore these brutal murders in hopes of solving them.

Listen to Unraveled

  1. Tenfold More Wicked 

Investigative journalism at its finest, Tenfold More Wicked is a blend of both narrative nonfiction and research. Focusing on a single case for episodes at a time, Kate Dawson shines a spotlight on crimes lost to history. This true crime podcast delves into the intimate lives of both the victims and their killers. 

Listen to Tenfold More Wicked

  1. Who Killed Emma?

This bone chilling crime podcast tells the story of missing persons case, Emma Caldwell. An investigation four years in the making, journalist Sam Poling is finally convinced she knows who killed Emma. This BBC produced podcast involves sex, rape, lies and murder. This tragic story will leave you deeply invested in finding who killed twenty-seven year old Emma. 

Listen to Who Killed Emma?

  1. My Favorite Murder

One of the best banter based, true crime podcasts, My Favorite Murder has one of the largest cult followings seen by the true crime community. Lifelong fans themselves, hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark unite forces each week, to retell their favorite true crime stories. These stories range from harrowing near misses with murderers to house hauntings. If you enjoy comedy sprinkled in, to lighten your true crime obsession, this podcast is for you. 

Listen to My Favorite Murder

  1. Dr. Death 

The average person’s worst nightmare, the story of Dr. Death will leave you clinging to the edge of your seat. Seemingly honest and personable neurosurgeon, Christopher Dunsch, reveals a dark, sinister side. Leaving thirty of his patients permanently injured or dead, this podcast goes into depth of his story. This true crime podcast is Grey’s Anatomy with a sick twist.

Listen to Dr. Death

  1. Jensen and Holes: The Murder Squad 

This podcast provides listeners the unique experience of being involved in a true crime investigation. Retired cold case investigators, Billy Jensen and Paul Holes take on cold cases each week. This podcast actively encourages their listeners to use their social media platforms to help solve crimes. Tips from listeners, DNA searches and social media geo targeting help these detectives solve forgotten cases, and give closure to victims’ families. Through using their broad listener base, they hope to inch closer to justice.

Listen to The Murder Squad

  1. The Clown and the Candyman

On a scale from one to twisted, this podcast is especially dark. The Clown and the Candyman provides a deeply disturbing insight into 1970’s America. Clown and the Candyman takes a deep dive into a pedophile network established in the 70’s, comprised of prominent figures from society. Some infamous serial killers that make appearances in this podcast include John Wayne Gacy and Dean Corll. 

Listen to The Clown and the Candyman

  1. The Apology Line: 

In the late 1980’s, posters with a mysterious hotline began emerging across New York City. The Apology Line tells the mysterious story of Allan Bridge, also known as Mr. Apology. This phone line quickly became an outlet for those needing to anonymously apologize for crimes they have committed. To his surprise, thousands of apologies came flooding in through this hotline. Apologies and confessions ranging from petty theft to murder. Told through the eyes of his wife, this podcast dives into the secret life of Mr. Apology, and of his mystery callers. 

Listen to The Apology Line

  1. 90s Crime Time 

Presenting a new crime each week, Simone Tayler transports listeners back in time, landing in 90s America. Her podcast revolves solely on crimes, ranging from petty theft to murder, that occurred between 1990 and 1999. Many of these crimes, lost within the pages of time, were largely unknown by the true crime community. That is of course, until she unearthed them. 

Listen to 90s Crime Time

  1. Red Collar 

This true crime podcast tells the story of the murderers who walk undetected, within the professional world. High level executives, CEOs and elected officials are some of the criminals mentioned in this series. When threatened or exposed, these individuals often resort to violence to protect their financial standing and status. Catherine Townsend descends into the inner workings of these real American psychos as they kill in plain sight. 

Listen to Red Collar

  1. Hunting Ghislaine with John Sweeney 

Hunting Ghislaine reveals the story of Ghislaine Maxwell finally being brought to justice. For an entire year after the case on Jeffery Epstein was exposed, Maxwell hid in the shadows. Although her role in the sexual exploitation and abuse of underage women was undeniable, it took the authorities twelve months to convict her. This story investigates how she became involved and her role in one of the largest pedophilic rings in the world. 

Listen to Hunting Ghislaine with John Sweeney

  1. Killer Fun

Throughout this podcast series, Christy and Jackie explore TV shows, movies and books that revolve around both real and fictional crime. Their aim is to take their listeners on a harrowing journey, filled with both entertainment and terror. Christy, currently enrolled in Psychology at Harvard, provides a unique edge in understanding the fascinating world of true crime. 

Listen to Killer Fun

  1. Crime Junkie

Each week Ashely Flowers provides straightforward storytelling on the missing, murdered and wanted. She features episodes covering stories of stalkers, conspiracy theories, serial killers, missing and murdered cases, mysteries and disappearances and more. If you enjoy skipping the small talk and banter of true crime shows, this podcast is for you.

Listen to Crime Junkie

  1. Park Predators 

While thousands of people flock to America’s beautiful parks every year, there are predators who lay and wait for their opportunity to kill. Park Predators is the true crime podcast that covers the trail of bodies left by serial killers within our National Parks. Sometimes the most beautiful places are not as they seem. 

Listen to Park Predators

  1. Girl Taken

Rob Lawrie, a former soldier, risked everything to help a seemingly innocent man, smuggle his daughter across the French border. He just needed to get his daughter to safety, or so he pleaded. As this podcast unfolds, it is revealed that there is a much darker side to this man’s story. Investigative Journalist, Sue Mitchel and Rob Lawrie document as they set out to find this young girl across the border. They hope to find her, before it’s too late.

Listen to Girl Taken

  1. Fatal Voyage: The Mysterious Death of Natalie Wood

This true crime podcast delves into the legendary disappearance of hollywood actress, Natalie Wood. The mystery surrounding her disappearance has had investigators perplexed for the last four decades. Wood was reported to have accidentally fallen overboard, off of a pleasure cruise. However, the hint of a deeper more sinister motive still lingers in the air. This twelve episode podcast follows Los Angeles homicide detectives who are attempting to solve this case, once and for all. 

Listen to Fatal Voyage: The Mysterious Death of Natalie Wood

  1. Southern Fried True Crime 

Down to earth and with a southern charm, Erica Kelley explores historical and current true crimes that have taken place in the Deep South. As a native Tennessean herself, she tells all her stories with a mild southern drawl, which is impossible not to get swept in by. Released weekly, the Southern Fried true crime podcast explores family murders, mysterious disappearances, poisonings and more.

Listen to Southern Fried True Crime

  1. Hunting Warhead 

This true crime and mystery podcast covers an international investigation, years in the making. Forums hidden in the deepest corners of the internet are found to hold shocking pieces of incriminating evidence. This evidence revealing some of the largest child abuse websites on the dark web. Journalists in Hunting Warhead work hard to unveil the abuse and put these predators behind bars. 

Listen to Hunting Warhead

  1. Affirmative Murder

Hosted by Alvin Williams and Francel Evans, this podcast covers murders that have taken place within marginalized communities. Affirmative Murder aims to shed light on the darker side of true crime. Through the lense of comedy, Alvin and Francel cover stories each week, educating us on how oppressed communities are impacted by crime. 

Listen to Affirmative Murder

  1. Anatomy of Murder

Taking a magnified view, former NYC homicide prosecutor, Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi and former Deputy Sheriff Scott Weinberger provide insider intel to homicide cases. This podcast gives an insight into what being on the ground, during a murder investigation, would feel like. 

Listen to Anatomy of Murder

  1. Killer Queens 

Tyrella and Tori, podcasts hosts and sisters, engage listeners with their complete obsession with everything true crime. This conversation based podcast will transport you into the world of each crime filled story. They cover all of the best aspects of true crime, such as murder, betrayal, mysteries and more. All while maintaining a southern sass. 

Listen to Killer Queens

  1. Redhanded 

Redhanded provides your weekly dose of murder through the vehicle of anecdotal, British, banter. Suthi and Hannah cover everything from infamous serial killers, to hauntings, possession and bizarre mysteries. Anything that borders on true crime or murder mystery, Redhanded is there to provide you with satirical humor and bone chilling facts. 

Listen to Redhanded

What Do You Think Are the Best True Crime Podcasts?

That’s our list of the best true crime podcasts in 2020. They’re full of interesting stories, tragic experiences, and compelling drama. Do you have a favorite show? Tell us which shows you think are the best true crime podcasts in the comments.

Still browsing for more great podcasts to add to your routine? Check out some more of our roundups:

Grow Your Audience with Castos

Try Castos for free for 14 days. See how it helps you create great content and connect with your listeners.

Start My 14-Day Free Trial

Photo of author
Dennis is a content marketer and web developer with years of experience helping startups and small businesses build their online platforms. He lives in Connecticut with his wife and daughter.

1 thought on “The 23 Best True Crime Podcasts (Like Serial and S-Town) [Updated May 2021]”

  1. Tenfold More Wicked. An awesome historical true crime podcast. Season 1, Edward Rulloff. Upstate New York toremented a fmily for something like twenty years. Season two is just as good. It’s about Burke and Hare in early 19th century Scotland. Episodes drop weekly.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Resources

More from Castos